In the nineteenth century the banker Ivan Bloch anticipated that another great European war would produce an attritional, brutal, bloody stalemate between the belligerents that would end with state collapse and left-wing revolution. This was not an oracular pronouncement on his part, but a thoroughly considered assessment grounded in long study of the advances in firepower, fortification and mobilization of Europe's military systems evident in his time, and the structure of the alliances through which those militaries were connected. And the result was such that in hindsight we can judge it to have been, in a way giving the lie to the ever-fashionable stupid sneering of the epistemological nihilists about the impossibility of trying to understand the world and where it is going, exceedingly accurate.
Indeed, the more far-seeing of Bloch's day found his case powerfully argued and highly persuasive, and such as H.G. Wells, standing on the shoulders of the giant, glimpsed things still further off. However, those who actually had any power at all regarding the policies of nations dismissed Bloch's warning, frankly because what Bloch told them was simply unpalatable to them. After all, that great power war had ceased to be anything but an instrument of national suicide was unacceptable for elites, addicted as they were to Malthusian-Social Darwinist misanthropy; slaves as they were to the imperatives of economic and thus also imperial expansion in an age of "finance capital"; and attached as they were to martial pomp and circumstance, not only as a function of the "persistence of the Old Regime" of landowner-warriors as the officer class, and, even more perverse, the insistence that war as essential to society's "hygiene" and health. The collective effort of war, after all, forced "unity" on the nation, bringing out the revivifying "best" in a society going "slack" and decadent"--which is to say that they were ever eager for those occasions in which they could set aside the democracy for which they had such distaste, divert the have-nots from concern for their unmet needs and violated rights, demand their subordination to those they told them all the time were their "betters," and give the security state an excuse such as peace did not afford them to crush with an iron fist those who did not obey (outlawing strikes, jailing dissenters). Additionally, as Thorstein Veblen had it, the mobilization for war gave all directly involved, above all the young men subject to the brutality and brutalization of life in uniform, a "training in ceremonial precedence, arbitrary command . . . unquestioning obedience," and in respect for and subordination to "rank" and "authority," which conditions the individual to servility--which is exactly how those in charge like it. And if war could be bloody, well, those elites' combination of Medieval contempt for the lower orders with that very nineteenth century Malthusian-Social Darwinism meant that those "leaders" were not squeamish about spilling a little, or a lot, of proletarian blood, the better to thin out the ranks of a burgeoning, unruly, dangerous working class--decreasing a particularly unwanted portion of the "surplus population." All in all, it was a win for the status quo and its greatest beneficiaries in that way that had George Orwell reminding his readers that whoever the foreign enemy is supposed to be at the moment, it is the proles the rulers are fighting first and foremost and always--a view most certainly affirmed by the historical record as Jacques Pauwels demonstrates in his all too fittingly titled The Great Class War, 1914-1918, not least in the attitude generals genuinely deserving of condemnation as sociopathic as well as monstrously incompetent displayed as they ordered millions of young men to "go over the top," and how they responded when so many of them left their bones in No Man's Land.
Looking at the killing fields of Ukraine, and what the drone has done and is doing now here and on other global battlefields, it seems that large land wars must, again, be protracted World War I-like contests, effort from which today's "generals" and "statesmen" seem no more likely to shrink than their predecessors of a century ago. Quite the contrary, they show themselves as eager for such as they have ever been as they gleefully tell their publics that their "vacation from history" is over, that the "peace dividend" from the end of the Cold War can no longer be paid out (as if they ever got it, as if spending wasn't rebounding by the time of the Kosovo War and especially after 2015 overtaken Cold War levels in real terms!), that (not as if they haven't heard this one before) the welfare state is no longer affordable and such frivolous nonsense as care of the sick and aged must be sacrificed for the "greatest public benefit of all," the preparation for war, War, WAR! which requires that the lower orders SHUT UP about their problems getting through the day and rally round the flag.
Of course, were the "generals" and "statesmen" of today to look at how the delusions of the "generals" and "statesmen" of 1914 ended they would not be nearly so cavalier about such a course, but they regard themselves as "elected to lead, not to read," and even where they do read it isn't the likes of Pauwels that they do read. Rather it is the right-wing revisionists who have been rehabilitating the First World War, spinning its victims into "heroes," remembering whom in the interviews promoting their Establishment crapola they wipe away a tear from their eye in sentimentality over the "patriotism" of those who "laid down their lives for their country," rather than sadness for those mass-murdered by their "leaders." You get more truth in an episode of Blackadder Goes Forth--which is why Michael Gove-like Upper-Class Twits of the Year hate it so.
Further Thoughts: What Made the Greatest Generation "Greatest?"
Considering the '90s mania for "the Greatest Generation" it helps to remember that two world wars and the arrival of the nuclear age did not cure the right of its belief in the virtues and necessity of militarism and war for the health of a nation. This is because of what the right fears and hates even more than it can ever hate the destruction war means, egalitarianism, especially as manifest in the ability and willingness of the have-nots to demand their rights. For the right it is not war but egalitarianism that is the disease, and militarism and war a cure--because it diverts attention from social questions, affords excuses to rein in democracy and civil liberties, and exacts "sacrifices" from those have-nots they think still have more than they deserve (all as in victory and sometimes even in defeat wartime means that the haves get to look forward to becoming have-mores as government cracks down on organized labor, hands out its contracts, and even temporary victory brings its spoils). Such is the "unity" the right so extolls--the word in the mouth of an Establishment speaker on this occasion or any other invariably meaning the disenfranchised not join hands with their more privileged countrymen in "compromise" of the kind that the "consensus" addict so much sings, but rather the unconditional surrender for which consensus is so much a smarmy euphemism as in the name of unity and consensus the poor do not let their "selfish" ideas about their "needs" get in the way of the selfishness of the rich.
During the Cold War the country had its militarism and its war, often war-of-a-kind, but not infrequently hot wars too. It was not all the right would have liked, even a Ronald Reagan not aggressive enough for the "invade Nicaragua!" crowd, but all the same, they largely got their way here. And if they were ecstatic over the fall of the Soviet bloc they rushed to declare The End of History the end of the Cold War left a void, one you can see neocon thought-leaders whining about in the pages of Foreign Affairs. Of course, there were ways to fill it, and in which they did fill it, insuring that the post-Cold War armed forces and their place in American life were really just "Cold War thinking on a smaller scale," and in the extolling of what Emmanuel Todd was to call the "micro-militarism" of the intervention-packed '90s, as "militainment" drenched pop culture from video gaming to television shows.
There was also the promotion of reverence for the militarism and warfare of a past era, ideally the one that came closest to their ideal of unity," World War Two, or rather their myth of World War Two, in which on hearing of the bombing of Pearl Harbor America's young men, in a fit of nationalistic rage and Johnny Rico "I'm Doing My Part" spiritedness, rushed to the recruiting stations without prompting, and the country rallied around the Leader (not the Leader they would have preferred, but the War Leader all the same) as it girded itself for a years-long struggle against the Enemy, without dissent or a peace movement, without misgivings about shoving Japanese-Americans into concentration camps, or the restrictions and deprivations on the home front that saw the profits and assets of Corporate America and the super-rich wax great on the basis of taxpayer-built plant as working people watched the rise in the prices of daily necessities outstrip their wages, or the incineration of foreign civilians by bomber fleets en masse, just the conviction that we were the Good Guys and the Enemy the Bad Guys and patriotic "sacrifice" in a "Get it done!" spirit as those young men who rushed to the recruiting stations "Yes sirred!" MacArthur and Patton all the way to V-J Day and the big ticker-tape parade, hooray! A war the more convenient because many in the younger cohorts which participated in that war were still around, living examples to the youth--to, with the help of Messrs. Brokaw and Ambrose be held up to them as the greatest generation because of that Yes-sirring and Getting-it-done in gleefully invidious contrast with the Gen X slackers of the ironic and extreme '90s, a generation cynical rather than revolutionary as F. Scott Fitzgerald had it and so not so threatening as the youth of those horrible, horrible '60s who weren't so cynical (and indeed the right was eventually to fall in love with Gen X, for their conservatism and conformism and privatism as they helped make Silicon Valley the hope and darling of the oligarchs), but still their cynicism a distant second-best relative to the earnest patriotism they really wanted to see in them. And so, the more easily in as the side of the war that Mailer and Jones, Heller and Vonnegut (veterans of the war all) presented made little impression on the imaginations of a generation that read less and read less well than its forebears, they gave them their version of World War II, which reached them even if they never read Brokaw or Ambrose (again, they were not readers), while the claqueurs of the media helped make sure that Terence Malick's take on the war got a lot less viewers than Steven Spielberg's, and it may be that Medal of Honor and Call of Duty had an even greater shaping effect on the minds of the young than that.
So far as I can tell the historical consequences of all that have been little parsed by our "intellectuals"--what, for example, all the encomiums to the Greatest Generation meant when war came in the twenty-first century, whether the example the right so wanted to give them had the desired effect, and what it meant for America's politics. However, it seems clear that the attitudes of the young changed, for reasons in which the propaganda of war and the reality of war were but one factor. There is, of course, a great deal of disputation about the nature of the change, reflected in how we have moral panic about the supposedly crisis-afflicted young adults of America in every conceivable flavor. Thus do what pass for "liberal" publications warn their readers that Andrew Tate is father figure to the current generation of young men, while the publications of the right instead panic their readers that they think about their personal "gender identity" as if it were merely a Baskin Robbins' flavor--thirty-one to choose from!--or even just giving up on adulthood generally to spend all day playing video games in their parents' basements and trying to become lawfully wedded to the glorified autocompletes they deludedly think are their "girlfriends.") Still, for all the incoherence and sheer stupidity evident in the portrayals there is perhaps the grain of truth that amid everything that is going on in the world in this age of polycrisis making what has for so long been the conventional wisdom look ever more fatuous, something's gotta give.
No comments:
Post a Comment