Thursday, May 19, 2022

The Discrete Silence On Authors' Pasts

Once upon a time I was struck by how little is said of writers' pasts in those biographical blurbs on the back of the hardcover book dust jacket.

Eventually I realized it was because the biographical blurbs, in the interest of a sales-promoting glamorization, avoided a great many of the grimy realities of the writing life. Thus they do not bring up the crummy day jobs writers often work to pay the bills until they can get a break (teaching English, for example—indeed, I suspect this is one of the things that keeps college English departments in adjunct labor, in spite of the horrendous pay and terms).

Thus does it also go with the crummier writing jobs writers often do before they hit the big time. I had a recent reminder of this over at the blog Paperback Warrior, which covers a range of material (I have seen work as diverse as Jack London's classic The Sea-Wolf and X-Files tie-ins discussed there), but concentrates on older work from the "pulpy" end of the spectrum--old hard-boiled stuff and the like. Most of the items Paperback Warrior presents are books reviews, but the blog occasionally presents broader, more background-oriented pieces. The one I have in mind now served up an overview of the history of the Nick Carter franchise, extending to its Nick Carter: Killmaster incarnation--one of innumerable '60s-era reinventions of older action heroes along James Bondian lines, with the old detective become a globetrotting secret agent. The resulting series ultimately had 263 installments between 1963 and the 1990s-era collapse of the action-adventure market.

One of the more interesting aspects of the series is the number of writers who worked on it, often under pseudonyms, before moving on to "A grade" hardcover work under their own names, and sometimes becoming fairly big names. Among them was David Hagberg, who wrote twenty of the Nick Carter novels on the way to becoming a major name in spy and techno-thriller fiction with his Kirk McGarvey books. One did not find the Nick Carter books included under the "Also By" heading in the front matter of his books. After all, he was an A-grade hardcover bestseller now, and we were not to think of him as anything else.

Such facts make the eternal whine of the Park Avenue types about the public's misperceptions of the business the more ironic. They complain that the public thinks it's much easier to become an author than it really is. But they certainly played their part in creating the illusion by eliding, among so much else, the apprenticeships from the record that convert old hands into apparent overnight successes--and of course, one can hardly credit them with worrying overmuch about the existence of apprenticeship opportunities, which have been dwindling for a long time. They shrank with the disappearance of the fiction magazine market and its openness for short form fiction (as Isaac Asimov forthrightly acknowledged in Earl Kemp's Who Killed Science Fiction?), and then shrank again when the more limited opportunities afforded by the old paperback market, and series' like Nick Carter, shrank in their turn. In this way as in every other today's aspiring writer is very much on their own, with no helping hand to be expected from anyone.

Further Thoughts (November 19, 2026): Of Authors' Biographies
I have never been a particularly enthusiastic reader of biographies. As A.J.P. Taylor remarked in an essay (you can find it in his old collection From Napoleon to the Second International), biography treats the individual as everything and society nothing, and this has never seemed to me satisfactory from an explanatory standpoint--all as, I might add, the vast panorama of history holds more interest for me than the usually all too commonplace minutiae of individual lives. (Yes, unfashionable as it is to say so, in the battle of literary standards between Henry James and H.G. Wells I stand with Wells as much as ever I did.)

Still, I have read a fair number of biographies over the years, with, probably unsurprisingly given my research interests, these disproportionately biographies of authors. More often than not they disappointed me. The lives of the authors they tell about are usually far less interesting than the authors' work--all as the biographies generally had little to say about what brought me to them in the first place, namely their work. What I wanted was the fullest portrayal, the fullest understanding, of their influences, the passions that fired them, the problems of craft they dealt with. Instead the biographer was apt to tell us who they slept with. This was not necessarily irrelevant to their work, but the biographer usually didn't show that it was relevant, and much more often seemed to be telling us who they slept with because it was an incident in their lives, the kind of incident far more people are interested in than the sort of things I was looking for (I don't know why; if you want to read about a "glamorous sex life," as Taylor had it, writers aren't the most promising candidates); and even when one suspected that it might have been relevant, treated it as they did because reporting the fact or allegation of the affair is easier than reconstructing the creation of a work of art and the part of the affair in it.

The suspicion seems to me affirmed by the fact that authors' autobiographies tend to be more satisfactory that way, writers, as it happens, often quite eager to discuss their work. Certainly a large part of the interest of Wells' Experiment in Autobiography for me has been Wells, relatively late in his career and so with the benefit of great self-awareness as well as hindsight, discussing his literary and other ideas in considerable detail.

Likewise Theodore Dreiser's A Book About Myself, if dealing with his life before he turned to writing fiction (indeed, just his career as a newspaperman), gives us a clear view of what was to drive him as a writer (his social and other frustrations, his anguish at the hard necessities he faced, what he saw of the world as a journalist, etc.), with, indeed, the seeds of his masterpiece An American Tragedy all too evident in his retelling of this critical early portion of his life. That made those particular biographies very much worth my while--and that, alas, all too rare in my experience of the field.

No comments:

Subscribe Now: Feed Icon