Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Of the 2026 Midterm Election

The commentariat widely expected that the 2026 midterm election would see the Democratic party make significant gains at the expense of the Republicans.

This expectation did not require any great thought on their part. Midterm elections usually see the party holding the White House take a (usually, well-deserved) beating as voters express their outrage over the ways in which those they elected betrayed them. (Indeed, it can seem that voting the scum out of office is the only satisfaction the voter gets in a system where policymaking is all too demonstrably oligarchical.) Exceptions to this rule have been few indeed, all as such reversals for "the party in power" are especially severe in years when said party, at a time of economic hardship for the many, was brazen in betraying its promises, and indeed worsened the pain of the public with its actions as it snarled "SHUT UP!" in their faces--as, after promising action on the "affordability crisis" on day one, and a policy of peace, the Republican party most certainly delivered the opposite since the election of 2024. (Indeed, one can hardly avoid being struck by how a President who, as Max Blumenthal reminded his readers, gained critical support in the early part of his bid for the presidency through his denunciation of the Bush the Second administration's neoconservative march through the Middle East and attacked the 2003 invasion of Iraq as "the worst decision we ever made" delivered another war of--not the people's--choice in the Persian Gulf in the name of curbing the threat of "Weapons of Mass Destruction" through the overthrow of a long-demonized regime that quickly proved not to be the easy "regime change" promised at the outset, and then determined to "stay the course," even as the consequences for the world proved far graver, and certainly the consequences for the American citizen more immediate.) Still, the media's response to the outcome of the election has been astonishment at how severe the Republicans' losses have been. Reporting the "flipping" of seats across regions and levels and branches of government they tell us again and again how Democratic party politicians have got elected in districts and states where this had seemed nearly unthinkable as they use over and over again such words as "landslide" and "historic," all as those inevitably lamenting the event, speaking of a near extinction-level event," find their words getting a lot of play.

Hearing such words I become instinctively suspicious. After all, our media, and its preferred "experts," have not exactly distinguished themselves as having a capacity for "big picture" and "long term" thinking. Quite the contrary, they shun such things, even while being prone to hot-take-diarrhea-of-the-mouth--worsened by their sensationalist impulses and associated propensity for being at once vague and hyperbolic. This deficiency was certainly on display when they covered a different election in 2024 they described as a landslide--the British General Election, which the media described Keir Starmer as "winning" by a landslide, setting the stage for a new era in British politics. In fact what really happened was that the vote for the two major parties was exceedingly weak, with the vote for the Tories collapsing, as rather than the votes not going to them going to Labour (which won in 2024 with less of the vote than it lost with in 2017 and 2019), third parties were the beneficiaries. Indeed, the far right Reform UK seemed potentially on the verge of eclipsing the Conservatives as Labour eclipsed the Liberals in the years after World War I--all as Starmer's Labour, so much damaged by his betraying his early posturing as a socialist/social democrat from very early on in his tenure as party leader as he revealed himself a Blairite, with a Manifesto to match, seemed to me to have only a very weak base of support, with all that meant for Starmer's chances of still occupying 10 Downing Street come 2029. Everything I have seen since has only affirmed that reading of the situation, as Reform UK waxed powerful--and helped Starmer's opponents on the right take advantage of the Jeffrey Epstein scandal to see Starmer out the door barely two years after his taking office, with Andy Burnham never showing much promise of representing a meaningful break with what Starmer delivered (and that less and less all the time as he sends the British air force to the Middle East).

The precedent seems to me meaningful for 2026 not simply as a reminder of the illiteracy of our "experts," but because the 2026 election was less a triumph of the party of opposition than the collapse of a party of government that had deeply alienated the public. The American electorate voted against the Republicans, much more than it did for the Democratic party, which has conducted itself very much in line with its tradition of recent decades of trying very hard to not stand for anything--and succeeded in part because in contrast with the British system there was that much less room for third parties. At the same time one ought not go too far in overstating just how much of the vote the Democratic party got in the circumstances, appreciating which it seems to me fitting that we look at the election to the House of Representatives as a way of putting the matter into perspective. After all, in contrast with the state level races this one gives us the national picture--and more clearly than the Senate race does because where only one-third of the seats in the upper house of Congress are up for challenge in any election, every seat in the House is that every two years. At the last count the Democratic party had won some 257 seats, with the possibility existing of their picking up a few more with a handful of races as yet "uncalled," suggesting in any event a rough three-fifths of the House. But what does that really amount to in American politics?

At this point a little history lesson is in order. As it happens, from the 1932 election that brought in Franklin Delano Roosevelt (FDR) and ultimately the New Deal, to 1992, the Democratic Party won a majority in the House in every election save those of 1946 and 1952, with the latter translating to near-total predominance for sixty-two years, and in the later period predominance for thirty-eight straight years. Notably that predominance survived the departure of the conservative Democratic South for the Republican party, and the ups and downs of the turmoil of the late '60s and '70s (the divisions over the Vietnam War and anti-civil rights backlash, the ways in which James Carter disappointed working people, etc.), these troubles narrowing but not eliminating the Democratic party's lead, which remained considerable. The post-Watergate bump they benefited from so much in 1974 and 1976 apart (which gave them over 290 seats in that period) they averaged 256 seats from 1966 to 1992, with the last year seeing them close to the average with 258 seats in the 1992 election.

The 1990s saw the Democratic Party's position collapse, however, in a way from which it has not recovered since, with 1994 a signal year here, the Democratic Party going from 258 to 204 seats in a single year--a loss of 54 seats, over a fifth of those it held, in just one election, paving the way for the Republicans winning a majority of the seats in the House in the next five elections. (Indeed, looking at the figure below, showing the distribution of seats in the House from 1962 to 2026, you can see how the Democratic party's position went off a cliff in 1994.) Of course, the Democratic Party finally won a majority in the House in 2006, but this did not usher in a new era of Democratic predominance. The party won majorities in the House in only four of the next ten elections, in 2008, 2010, 2018 and 2020, with of these majorities only 2008 seeing it achieve the kind of preponderance that in the pre-Clinton era it took for granted (257 seats), with the next election already seeing a pointed drop (to 242), the majority party turned into the minority party in the one immediately after that, with a virtually unheard of mere 201 seats in 2012, and still worse than that in 2014 and 2016, and their average consistently far lower than it had been over the twentieth century (214 in 2010-2024, reflecting the norm of their slight or nonexistent control).

Figure: Seats in the House of Representatives by Party Affiliation


It seems to me that this history poses an obvious question, namely will the Democratic party's far from unprecedented position here prove the beginning of a prolonged dominance of the House, or will it prove a blown chance such as what was seen in 2006-2010? Answering that I direct you to what exactly happened at the key turning points, with the events of the "Republican Revolution" of 1994 exemplary. Conventionally attributed to the efforts of the Republican leadership in bringing about that outcome, like most major victories it is inconceivable without real blundering on the losing side, with key to the success of the '94 "revolution" how newly elected Democratic President Bill Clinton betrayed his supporters. Admittedly when one considers Clinton's platform one finds it studiedly vague in important ways, its text appealing to public anger amid what was then "the worst economy since the '30s" over "Reaganomics" while not being too clear regarding what he would offer as an alternative--the expert able to recognize in him a "Neo-Liberal" who would likely govern as a neoliberal. (Indeed, Clinton did not hesitate to display a good deal of "Big Government"-hating conservatism here, and in hindsight to mark himself as the prototypical Third Way-flogging hustler that the likes of Tony Blair would emulate.) Still, "Slick Willie" at the least left room for those not looking too closely or critically at his record and statements to mistake him, if not for the Second Coming of FDR, for a producerist-nationalist who would offer some corrective to the preceding disastrous twelve years of thoroughly neoliberal Republican administration, whether in addressing the country's increasingly financialized and deindustrialized economy, or the shortfalls of its social safety net in areas like health care. However, he instead forwarded his predecessors' neoliberal policies with great gusto, doing much that he had claimed to oppose (going all out fighting for free trade agreements, giving a pass to violators of financial laws), and kicking to the curb what he had promised to do (health care reform, address of energy and the environment), in an economy that went on financializing, deindustrializing and shortchanging working people. Moreover, as he went about it, when he was not decoying the simple-minded with stupid stunts like his Attorney General's bluffing Hollywood about the Federal government getting tough with it unless it cleaned up its act with regard to violence on TV, he offered patronizing lectures about politics as the art of the possible, with (very centrist, this) the only thing that was possible giving oligarchs what they want as others get "I feel your pain"--and then when people didn't buy it, he said "Look" in that tone he used when showing irritation and impatience with inferiors, and repeated the same insult to their intelligence as he jabbed his thumb in their faces.

Admirers of grubby political maneuvering were impressed by this. Perhaps it is impressive. Certainly if one regards the goal of the political center as thwarting the demands of progressives and working people (as indeed it is), well, Clinton did that brilliantly by getting himself into the White House while destroying the public support for the party that from the standpoint of the "conventional wisdom" represented the "progressive" alternative to the fire-breathing right in lasting ways, giving his equally centrist successors an excuse to plead helplessness in the face of the right as indeed they not only enabled but pushed the continuation of the neoliberal program. And indeed, in spite of the grief the right gave him while he was in office (including the absurd and disgusting attempt to impeach Clinton over a personal indiscretion), he was feted and rewarded for it, as one is reminded considering how where after leaving office Jimmy Carter devoted himself to what one may sincerely regard as charitable works, Clinton kept a more rarefied company--as one sees when looking at that photo of him in Jeffrey Epstein 's indoor pool with Ghislaine Maxwell and "Unidentified Woman."

But few ever admit to this having been the Agenda, even for a Big Government-bashing, Old Liberal-hating Neo-Liberal hailed for being so in the New York Times itself by chief Neo-Liberal theoretician Charles Peters himself. Indeed, suggesting that centrist Democratic politicians can ever care more about stopping progressives than they do about winning elections (no matter how many, many times they blatantly do it) is the kind of thing that makes centrists sneer "conspiracy theory." So very well, let us for the moment accept that Clinton actually cared about winning elections for his party--by which standard he was a disaster for it from which his party did not even begin to recover for many, many years, and then less as a matter of its own merits than its rival party's demerits. Simply put, public disgust with George W. Bush's administration, largely in response to the war into which he had plunged the country (the war that, again, Donald Trump denounced as the worst decision the country had ever made), sufficed to make a good many people who had not done so in a while vote Democratic again.

But then Barack Obama, amid not just the war but an even graver economic crisis than the early '90s as the neoliberal utopianism of the '80s and '90s had its logical culmination in the wreck-the-world financial crisis in whose shadow we have all been living ever since, proved to be another centrist-neoconservative-neoliberal Democratic President who was to brag in his memoir about how he had stood for nothing at all, advised by the same pack of sleazy grifters who had filled Clinton's administration (e.g. that other friend of Jeffrey Epstein, the loathsome Larry Summers), and very predictably betrayed the country just as brutally and brazenly as his predecessor. (I remember seeing Matt Damon campaigning for Obama in person in 2008. His enthusiasm impressed me as genuine--without the qualification or reserve one might have expected from someone who personally knew and admired historian Howard Zinn growing up! Damon's enthusiasm was long gone by 2011, as he confessed in public--and Obama's retort as witless as it was shameless.) Unsurprisingly in 2012 the House was no longer Democratic Party-dominated, setting the stage for another round of Republican ascendancy(in much, much more than just the House in 2016, as the year's surprise presidential election outcome showed us), public backlash against an elected President who infuriated even his supporters, and another chance for the Democratic party in 2018, which made its admitted gains that its centrism-neoconservatism-neoliberalism-committed leaders blew yet again, even more quickly this time, leaving the party in the position of weakness from which in 2026 it is just reemerging.

As all this shows, those who voted Democratic in 2026, just as they did before, expect results, and whether people get them will decide whether 2026 is another 2008, or something more enduring, like the post-FDR majority. Considering that one has to take into account two factors. One is that if the Democratic Party has what looks like an impressive majority in the House it is not really better than it had many times in the past, even in the Obama era, when it did not amount to much, even in far more propitious circumstances. After all, not only is the Democratic lead slighter in the other house of Congress, where the prerogatives of Senators permit a minority the Republicans will clearly have to easily thwart a good deal of action, but the two other branches of government, the executive and the judiciary, remain firmly in the hands of the Republican right. From Donald Trump's reappointment of Stephen Miller to Chief of Staff, to Supreme Court Justices and Samuel Alito's making it clear that they will not be retiring anytime soon, they give little sign of willingness to make concessions to the discontents just expressed at the ballot box as they make the most of what is still a position very, very far from suffering "a near-extinction level event." There will thus be only so much that the Democratic Party's leaders can do with even the best will in the world--and such a will is not to be assumed on their part. For all of the attention claimed by the victories of progressive candidates the country over, from which progressives can take heart, in the extremely seniority-advantaging American legislature (conservative and change-averse as a feature, not a bug), the centrists-neoliberals-neoconservatives remain in charge, and it seems, unlikely to give the progressives any ground, certainly to go by Hakeem Jeffries. ("There will never be a moment where I bend the knee to hard-left democratic socialism." "Never a moment where I bend the knee?" Seriously? This is how you talk when facing an aggressor of overwhelming power, not a handful of junior members of your own party. And "hard-left?" To describe people simply calling for what Jimmy Carter, actually regarded as having been of the more conservative element in the party in his day, campaigned on?)

As things stand the Republicans seem likely to stay the course once again, and the Democratic Party leadership to enable them as they fight with "epic fury" against the progressives in their party while "reaching across the aisle" to the right no matter what it does not only in the name of "unity," "consensus" and all the rest of that claptrap, but under the pretext of its being all they can possibly do (such that they have to move right, right, ever to the right as they snarl at the progressives who would have it otherwise). Yet I do see the possibility of alternatives, with the most obvious the progressive elements in the Democratic Party challenging the prevailing centrists. This is all the more the case insofar as this encourages those in the Republican party those whose laments of their party's defeat, and the criticisms of the policies that led to it, are more than just an attempt to grab press attention, escape personal responsibility, attempt damage-control, gain an unwarranted reputation as a "maverick," etc. pragmatically "going their own way" in contrast with the deference they showed their party's leaders in the past, voting against the policies that have cost them dearly here than persisting in them.

I do not think any such reorientation of the parties to be very likely. As Ralph Miliband made clear, progressives are much more likely to become parliamentary rather than to make parliament progressive, with Alexandria "Woke 1 Was Crazy!" Ocasio-Cortez (no longer the newcomer, now a four-termer heading into a fifth) striking me as a contemporary reminder of that--the more in as the really progressive element seems very limited indeed for now. (For all we hear about the Democratic Socialists of America there are a mere seven of them in those 254+ seats the Democratic Party won, a scarce three percent of their own party, and that includes the aforementioned Ms. Ocasio-Cortez.)

Also not encouraging this is the tendency of American progressives to extreme complacency, and hasten to the conclusion that they have got what they wanted when they have in fact got nothing, have in fact left the field to an opponent who really was victorious, and afterward shrink from resuming the struggle. Consider how many times the end of neoliberalism has been announced since the bungle that was the Republican administration, down to the present. Consider how after the Republicans' ill-conceived impeachment attempt against Clinton many who should have known better (including Thomas Frank) rushed to pronounce the right's "culture war" as defeated, failed, finished. Consider how after the election of Barack Obama the opposition to the Iraq war evaporated, even as the wars not only continued but metastasized and spread, with Obama making "kill list Tuesdays" part of the rituals of the presidency, and Iraq followed by Libya, by Yemen, by Syria, and oh yes, the western Pacific and Ukraine, to almost no protest whatsoever.

Consider, too, how after the genuinely historic events of January 2021 progressives told (read: lied to) themselves that Donald Trump and "Trumpism" were finished as a force in American politics and even American life (thus was there silly talk of digitally erasing his cameo in Home Alone 2!), apparently little aware that in almost no time Trump would again be the candidate of a far more united and militant Republican party. Indeed, even with the Democratic Party once again sacrificing sound strategy and democracy itself to heading off any chance of a progressive candidate being on the ballot in a campaign that was a "greatest hits" edition of the electoral failures of the epoch, down to the very last Trump campaign rally in Madison Square Garden with all its dark evocations for many, its sympathizers discounted the possibility of Trump winning as they had eight years earlier, such that they were shocked when his victory in not just the Electoral Vote but the popular vote such as no Republican had had in two decades swept him into office, and he set about proving that the 47th presidency would not be like the 45th. Such is the grasp of HISTORY, even that history which has scarcely ceased to be current events, that our political culture, our media, promulgate, the more in as they also encourage the extreme shortness of attention span and susceptibility to distraction exemplified by the media's responding to the shootings of Renee Good and Alex Pretti in Minneapolis and the spreading protests in their wake, and the looming war with Iran, by blasting us with "All Nancy Guthrie, All the Time."

In the rhetoric I see at the time of this writing I see such complacency yet again, complacency even less warranted than it seemed to be in 2008, given, again, that as Greg Palast correctly pointed out, the Democratic party's position in government is a long way from what it was even then, and the party not even giving the false impression of direction that it seemed to have when facing a global financial-economic collapse and the task of ending what Americans have since come to call not the "Iraq war" but the "forever war." Yet just as on those other occasions "getting fooled again" is what those celebrating the election returns seem to be largely doing, and it can be expected that all of those who care to see that everything the American public voted against continue will make the most of that, just as they have done on every one of the occasions I have just cited. Those wondering if this time the American public's vote will amount to more than an expression of opposition without policy consequence to show for it as everything they voted against just goes on and on are thus advised to watch for whether the complacency, the self-deception, and the acquiescence to which it ultimately leads are repeated in exactly that way elites are counting on, because they have so consistently got it in the past.

2 comments:

Dominic Parker said...

Hi Nader! Thanks for this insight!

Obviously I have lots of thoughts of my own regarding the midterms results. And I do agree with most of your points (though again, I do still believe the worst-case outcome of this blue wave will always be better than the alternative of the status quo techno/neo/ultra-nationalist GOP majority remaining in power). If nothing else, having at least some hope that minor reforms could emerge is likely mentally beneficial to all than the "doom and gloom" of the mainstream viewpoints.

I'd be interested to see how this election will affect the 2028 election - more specifically, how it affects Trump's bid for a third term. Will he go for it? And if he does, would it be 2024 all over again - or something else entirely? I'm actually not quite sure myself. Perhaps the outcome of the Iran war or the political battles over ICE will determine that instead, but who knows?

Nader said...

And thanks again for reading. Certainly for those at all unhappy with the country's direction, the election is a positive development, even those with no confidence in the Democratic party, who see in at least a repudiation of the policies of the last two years, with the outcome the more impressive because of all the redistricting, etc.. Still, the big fight now will be within the parties. Certainly on the Democratic side Schumer and Jeffries inspire no confidence in those hoping for change--but at the same time it is interesting how vocal progressives have managed to be about their dissatisfaction with the centrist leadership, much more than was the case in, for example, 2008 or 1992. It implies that even professional commentators can't look away from that, and that the voters may have learned, or are learning, something from past disappointment. That may amount to something yet, one way or another--though it will be easier to judge that in January--with whether or not we see change inside one or both parties (or lack of it) what I'm watching as a clue to 2028.

Subscribe Now: Feed Icon