Wednesday, November 18, 2026

The Politics of Celebrity

NOTE: The following items (What is Celebrity? A Definition," "The Politics of Celebrity," "The Politics of Celebrity Gossip") were originally going to be three separate posts. Since they were not very long, and very similar in theme, and followed so readily from one another, I decided to just put the three items together in a single post for convenience's sake.

What is Celebrity? A Definition
One might think of "celebrity" as a status in which an individual is not only well-known to the general public, but of interest to it for particular reasons and in particular ways. There is an expectation that they are known for positive reasons, and perceived positively, with admiration and affection related to their being superlative in some ways (in skill, accomplishment, some personal quality, etc.). However, it is also the case that the way in which they are superlative, or the area of life in which they are superlative, tends to be associated by ("stodgy," "puritanical") cultural authority with "frivolousness." One may also add that the affection and admiration of the public extends to an interest in them personally--in their personal life, such that gossip about it is of interest to a wide audience, and indeed the basis of a significant media industry trafficking in such gossip (as the profusion of tabloid journalism demonstrates).

Considering the matter is this one way one can see that many who are famous are not celebrities. A famous criminal despised by the public is not a celebrity, however fascinating they may be to some in other ways. A scientist may be well-known and highly regarded for their achievements, but these are not ordinarily considered frivolous, and popular affection and personal interest of the kind described here not ordinarily part of the package. Rather the description tends to fit persons in the world of the arts, entertainment and sport, especially insofar as the activities are popular--less the novelist or sculptor than the actor or singer, less the world champion in a sport aired only on "the Ocho" than one which fills stadiums and regularly draws audiences of tens of millions on television.

In that connection with entertainment one sees a suggestion of a key aspect of celebrity, performance. The scientists who has made a breakthrough in their field is not seen at their work by public--nor even the novelist or sculptor. The public only knows the result of their work, and especially where the matter is science, or to a lesser extent, high culture, the public only knows that the result is significant because authority tells it so. By contrast the public sees the actor, singer, athlete do what is supposed to make them superlative--the actor, singer, athlete, performing it before their eyes. And if likely to be swayed by hype, critical claquing and much else, nevertheless much better able to judge for themselves the performance, which can touch them very personally. Not everyone may be equally impressed, but those who are impressed are likely to be genuinely, personally so, making them into fans such as those who may be admired for other reasons (like scientists) tend not to have.

Moreover, the aspect of performance extends beyond what the celebrity does for their audience to their whole public persona, their life as a public figure, for they are "that thing they do" in extreme degree--at once one-dimensional and larger than life as they are likely to fill some established niche, like the tough guy action hero or the sex goddess, whose "lifestyle"--a word that for once can be correctly used here--is supposed to match the screen image, not just lavish and glamorous, but entailing a particular flavor of glamour consistent with that larger-than-life one-dimensionality. (Thus does the action star drive a Hummer for no practical reason whatsoever, but just because that is what big tough guys who beat up people on screen do. Thus is the sex goddess' bedroom and bathroom exactly what people would expect of a sex goddess.) One may add that the glamour significantly extends to their sex life--the more in as the celebrity is conventionally expected to be attractive, a "sex symbol" (in the case of the screen sex goddess, this is very central indeed to her celebrity stature, superlativeness in physical beauty and sexual allure in fact a basis for celebrity many a time), and have "high-profile" personal romances with other superlatively attractive celebrities. In all this these ways celebrities, who "have what you don't," embody fantasies for the public--fantasies of being some desirable thing in extreme degree and becoming rich and famous because of that, as well as the fantasies of luxury, fantasies of privilege, and yes, the fantasy of sex that are part of its mystique.

So altogether:
Celebrity is a kind of fame achieved by those regarded as superlative in some respect in a mass audience pleasure-giving area of life such as popular art, entertainment or sport. This typically entails performance on the part of the celebrity, whose public persona is expected to be of a piece with the performance in ways extending to a glamorous and luxurious "lifestyle" aligning with said persona, and entails "fan"-like admiration, affection and interest in the personal life of the performer on the part of a wide audience, exemplified by the attention afforded them by tabloids.
In all that one may also sense why some see celebrity as in decline today. The fragmentation of popular culture to which the digitalization of media is presently contributing means that there are fewer movies, shows, events, anything that "everyone" can be said to be following at one time, all as their involvements in them may be shallower--the old-fashioned "fan" perhaps less often seen. Certainly the way film production has changed has made the endurance of old-fashioned film star status questionable, all as the decline in the prominence of spectator sports within popular culture from what they were a few decades ago means that the sports hero is not what they were, the more in as the "media ecosystem" that permitted champions in one field to expand their profile beyond it seems a thing of the past. It may be that popular music is a rare exception to the pattern for now, certainly to go by the prominence of Taylor Swift, but it seems that the trend is likely to catch up the singers in time, the more in as concert-going is ceasing to be affordable for the so-called "middle class," all as it is hard to think of any act that shows promise of ever matching Swift's fame . . .

Meanwhile, wokefied mainstream opinion's extreme hostility toward anything suggestive of traditionalism in gender, and especially to anything that would conventionally appeal as "sexy" to the sensibility of (the male) half of the population, has not sat easily with the "sex symbol," and all the rest that sex did for celebrity--and I suspect celebrity has suffered accordingly in this way as well. It also seems to me that the quasi-celebrity of, for example, the reality star (often superlative at nothing), and the online influencer (not only not superlative, but trafficking in the illusion of "relatability") has cheapened the fantasy of celebrity--while in a hard-bitten era, many may be less responsive to the selling of such fantasy more generally. Feeling more strongly that there is "us" here and the privileged "them" there, rather than finding in such personages an escape from their dreary existences, seeing celebrities, thinking about them, is a reminder of how crummy their life is that they can well do without.

The Politics of Celebrity Culture
Considering the politics of celebrity it may be well to start with a definition of celebrity. Here is what I have been able to come up with:
Celebrity is a kind of fame achieved by those regarded as superlative in some respect in a mass audience pleasure-giving area of life such as popular art, entertainment or sport. This typically entails performance on the part of the celebrity, whose public persona is expected to be of a piece with the performance in ways extending to a glamorous and luxurious "lifestyle" aligning with said persona, and entails "fan"-like admiration, affection and interest in the personal life of the performer on the part of a wide audience, exemplified by the attention afforded them by tabloids.
As one can see from this characterization of celebrity the concept, with its setting up a few for admiration and reward far above the many on the premise of their superlativeness in some degree, is inherently inegalitarian and elitist. One may also add to this that celebrity culture, in fostering popular affection toward, fascination with, identification with, at least part of a society's elite, serves to accommodate the public to the existence of inequality, reinforcing it. (Celebrity has the virtue of usually going along with youth, and exceptional attractiveness, charisma or charm, a far cry from what the business-and-politics power elite are apt to possess--they call it "Showbusiness for ugly people" for a reason, folks!--all as the celebrity's privilege can seem remote from such things as "surplus labor extraction" and "financial parasitism," the recording artist who got rich off of music sales as a result of working people freely paying for their songs capable of seeming a comparative innocent even in the eyes of a self-described communist.) This is all the more in as celebrity culture is connected with a culture of "You can do it too!" aspirationalism that has those discontented with their lot, rather than thinking about how society might be fairer to the disadvantaged, pinning their hopes on and pouring their efforts into personally becoming one of those greatest beneficiaries of a generally unfair and brutal system, and in the meantime believing themselves only "temporarily embarrassed billionaires." (Certainly many a person, especially the 99 percent-plus who have neither capital nor connections, picture becoming a famous actor, singer, writer as their best chance to really rise above their lousy lot in life.) One may add that celebrity also serves to promote interest in the cultural activities in which people became celebrities, helping sustain enthusiasm for popular culture, and sports, and unavoidably the value systems that they teach--again, apt to be status quo-affirming--the more easily in as there is so much in the makeup of the artistic and athletic mentalities that inclines them to the prevailing conservatism broadly in their work (the content of movies, songs, etc.), as they also readily lend their names, faces, time, effort, to conservative causes. Altogether this makes celebrity culture not just deeply conservative, but a prop to conservatism.

Such a conclusion may seem surprising given that from a "traditionalist" (stodgy, "puritanical," etc.) conservative cultural standpoint there may be much wrong with celebrity culture. There is its misanthropic suspicion of that which is "trivial" or gives pleasure generally, the more in as its content is so often "sensational," "salacious" or "irresponsible," the more in as it is to be enjoyed by working people--who in their view are not merely working people because they must sell their labor, but because they exist to work for the profit and comfort of their "betters"--and that they prefer those working people keep their minds on their work, on raising the generation of workers which will replace them (as those alert to the natalist concern understand, this is what "family" is all about for them), and the indoctrination which keeps them in their places and performing the function they allot to them (hence "faith" as well as "family"), all as they just plain begrudge the lower orders any and all comfort or happiness. There is also the plain and simple snobbery about "low" cultural "junk," the stronger for the broader elitism of the sensibility, and the anti-modern and antiquity-loving bent of so much conservatism.

Nevertheless, however widespread and far from unimportant this life-hating outlook is, few take it to its logical conclusion, with elites historically less averse to culture and sport than that. Quite the contrary, rather than opposing them their concern has tended to be to exercise control over their content, and indeed that desire what really stands in back of the severe, disapproving traditionalism, which has been such a useful tool for this purpose. By and large art has been ruling-class art, subsidized by elites to meet their personal tastes, or serve their political ends, such as propagandizing the many with the "right" ideas, as is to be seen in ways ranging from the iconography of temples, to the enlistment of Hollywood in contemporary war drives, all as they have long been sophisticated users of the star as spokesperson. Popular sport has even more thoroughly served their ends as a training not so much in the edifying mind-set and habits of "teamwork" and the like, but, as Thorstein Veblen had it, clannishness and truculence, in personal force and will ("He got it because he wanted it more") and superstition as the explanation of life's outcomes, making for a solid training in nationalism, militarism, and in more obscure ways, even religiosity. For his part Victor Klemperer was entirely right to remark the place of the "sports hero" in Nazi culture, while it does not seem at all accidental that Cold War America represented the high point for sports in American life. (Meanwhile the debased form of celebrity that reality TV offers flourishes in significant part because of its highly conservative content.) And indeed one may be struck by the way in which the idea of celebrity has been dragooned into the service of the most traditionalist of all institutions--as with the idea that providing a Britain where "We don't have a Hollywood!" with a celebrity culture justifies the retention of the royal family with all its power, privileges--and symbolism.

Altogether looking at a media outlet such as the Daily Mail I cannot help being struck by how it combines a heaping helping of the crudest sort of tabloid trashiness (recall how in their banner they arranged the faces of Beyonce Knowles, Kim Kardashian, Miley Cyrus, Victoria Beckham in almost Mount Rushmore-like fashion, a Mount Rushmore of the contemporary tabloid universe?) with the crudest sort of right-wing propaganda. The reality that conservatism of various kinds so much dominates the media makes comparison difficult, but meager as the left-wing media deserving of the name are I certainly do not know of any left-wing publication that attempts to hook readers with the latest on the Kardashians for the sake of getting them to listen to or read their take on the climate crisis or the Iran War. And indeed I suspect that if they tried to do that their target audience would laugh them off in contempt.

The Politics of Celebrity Gossip
Taking up the subject of celebrity culture and its politics a while ago it seemed plain enough that in its elitism and inegalitarianism, and its making elites and the existence of privilege itself attractive to the public, making the public even identify with them and hope to participate in what they have like so many "temporarily embarrassed billionaires," celebrity culture is inherently conservative. Accordingly lending itself very well to reinforcing cultural institutions promulgating conservatives attitudes and values (from professional sports to reality TV to "the British crown), it has in its effect been even more so. However, that does not quite exhaust the subject, with the actual content of so much celebrity gossip seeming to me to merit a word when we discuss the political implications of the phenomenon.

Consider what it is that the gossip-mongers tell us about the relevant personages. They give us stories of their rise in the world--telling us of how "ordinary" people just like ourselves got their "big break" when someone recognized something special in them and they became "overnight successes" like they "never dreamed of becoming." They tell us of how hard they work and how smart they are as they enumerate how they are a thousand things besides the one thing we know them for ("I don't just act and sing and dance, I'm a businesswoman and a philanthropist and an activist and an author!") every one of them Renaissance men and women who would be on this year's Nobel Prize winners list were they not grubbing for roles in crappy films of no value whatsoever. They tell us of the glamorous lifestyles (the word may be safely used here) those people now have--and how it can all go awry, as they tell us of the troubles that come with money, especially when a person inexperienced in handling large sums of it, especially when young, gets hold of a lot of it, exposing them to the dangers of self-indulgence, which might destroy them ("Too much, too soon," was a favorite cliché of the hack journalist, once upon a time), but which they might also overcome through personal "grit" and "faith" as, having "lost everything but got what is real" they come to appreciate "what really matters in life," which isn't the career and fame and glamour and luxury (even as they hold on to all those things for dear life).

Those who have thought at all seriously about the propaganda campaign the rich and their champions have waged against awareness and appreciation of the significance of class in America for the last two hundred years should easily recognize in all this drivel a compendium of its clichés. In the nobody who became a somebody because of that big break, the self-made man, who "proves" that social background is no advantage, or barrier, to "success" on the level playing field that is our meritocracy, on which talent and hard work will always show itself, always be respected, always have its reward, the more easily in that opportunity is everywhere. In the idea that "You can do it too!" and cease to be a temporarily embarrassed billionaire by becoming the real thing, because what's stopping you, after all? In the idea that in this way as in so many others the rich aren't different from you and me, except for their being hard-working and smart in the way you haven't been--else why are you down there and they up there?--but that at the same time they are probably not happier than you, probably less so, because of the tragedies that so often mar their existence, all as at any rate the enjoyment of wealth is fleeting ("shirtsleeves to shirtsleeves in three generations" the old cliché of a political line that ever downplayed the existence of such a thing as Old Money). All as while they are at it they give us a lecture on the evils of drugs and sex, and the virtue of religious belief, and generally the belief that the vileness of human nature is such that one must be ever kept down, their hands busy, the temptations out of reach if they are not to harm themselves or others, and practice in sitting in moral judgment on complete strangers of whom we know nothing.

The intelligent can only sneer, as they consider how unlikely it is for someone really born a nobody to become a somebody in Hollywood, how in this world very far from being a level playing field meritocracy rich in opportunity for all social privilege and outright nepotism not only played a large part in the making of those careers, but were often a sine qua non of them--all as they cannot but be struck by how shabbily defensive the beneficiaries of the system, like all other privileged persons, get, as if they really were victims of persecution, when anyone points out the reality (witness Jamie Lee Curtis' particularly self-pitying, obnoxious, foolish conduct). How for all the talk of their hard work--and some of it is admittedly hard, the long hours and physical discomfort of shoots, the sometimes grueling training--as is the case with even the hardest-working rich man that ever was a great many others work just as hard as they do, indeed harder, under far worse conditions, for far less in return, with far less choice about the matter. (Yes, it was painful getting into that costume. Ever mined coal, though? Gone down into the sewers as a maintenance worker? Toiled in a steel mill? Given the choice of that instead, which would you take?) And the talk of their "smarts" ("Smarter than you, smarter than you!" the media taunts us in line with its ultra-reactionary Social Darwinist prejudice and hatred of equality) proves just as specious, as their supposed Renaissance Man and Woman accomplishments fail to stand up to scrutiny, often a matter of mere dilettantism, or lending their names to other people's projects (lending their name to a fashion line, attending a dinner, accepting the byline on a ghostwritten book or article in an industry where Names count for everything and writing ability next to nothing ), all as a good many of them only remove all doubt as to whether they are a fool when they open their mouths, as they do far too often. Certainly in their attention to the sufferings of the rich they know all too well that there is nothing in those sufferings from which the poor are exempt, with indeed the rich getting every indulgence, every protection, such that they are permitted to survive and even thrive in the wake of what is likely to end the life of a poor person--and those understanding this groan at the ceaseless encomiums to "grit" and "faith" when the recognition for their "recovery," their "comeback," should go to lucre as they can only consider how very little attention the (vastly greater) sufferings of poor persons get by comparison with the sufferings of the rich who can far more easily rid themselves of their riches than a poor person can rid themselves of their poverty if they so desired, yet somehow never do. Indeed, even in the face of the complete ruin that is a rarer thing than the hype would have one believe, the celebrity is apt to have their money manager and their portfolio of assets giving them a share in our casino economy's paper profits, all as if really wiped out they can just write a tell-all or do another reality show or run for office, fame an asset they still have and which makes hard times a very different thing for even the much-mocked "D-lister" than for the true "nobody." And of course there is what this mountain of crassness and incoherence adds up to, the message that "No matter how deprived or repressed you are, how limited and unsatisfying your life, be grateful you are not them," even as you are enjoined, obliged, pressed, to strive upward economically, not least because it is so glorious to be them--incoherence all too much of a piece with the life-denying bourgeois outlook that one must sacrifice everything on the altar of "success," yet abstain from actually enjoying anything it brings them. Given all that it seems all too predictable that it is in the publications of the right, not the left, that blend gossip-mongering and propaganda.

No comments:

Subscribe Now: Feed Icon