Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Centrism, Democracy and the News Media

The political tendency that American discourse characterizes as "centrism," sometimes confusingly labeled "liberalism," is describable as in fact conservatism--certainly if by "liberalism" and "conservatism" one means the political philosophies of those names whose essential meanings have, among educated persons, retained significant constancy since the eighteenth century. Proponents of conservatism in this "classical" sense, which emerged and acquired definition in opposition to the rationalistic liberalism of the Enlightenment, denies the possibility of attaining the kind of deep, subtle, "big picture" knowledge of the complexities of the social world that would make it rationally controllable, dismissing claims to such knowledge as "ideology" and the proponents of such claims as "ideologues." (If, as Karl Marx had it, "To be radical is to grasp the root of a matter," a conservative is one who believes the radical to be chasing a dangerous illusion in thinking that they can do so--with Marx and Marxism epitomizing that danger.) Justifying themselves in significant part through reference to this "epistemological pessimism," the conservative is broadly averse to deliberate societal change, particularly change touching the economic and social spheres that conservatives conventionally insist be left outside of politics (the more in as they insist that interference with property is incompatible with the preservation of either freedom or order). Significantly the conservative also fears the "common man," of whose intelligence and responsibility as a political actor, and of whose ability to understand the issues of the day with even the greatest assistance, they have an abysmally low opinion (i.e. the "swinish multitude"). And they are particularly fearful of the radicalization and mobilization of "the masses" behind an ideology directed toward change, and the conflict or change that might result from that, epitomized by their horror that this would lead not merely to strife but to revolution and a political order in which an "ideological" dictatorship controls every aspect of a society's life, subordinating it to its program for change in a situation less free than before--in twentieth century terminology, "totalitarianism." They are thus inclined to demand the public's deference to the existing elite that "knows better," and whose sounder judgment it is in no position to gainsay. All this has its reflection in the practical accommodation of conservatism to liberalism's advance that defines "actually existing" conservatism (and liberalism) today--what one may call a "conservative liberalism" in which conservative thinking organizes and administers liberal institutions like representative government according to conservative principles for conservative ends, limiting the public's participation within the system, and its expectations of the results of that participation to adjustments preserving society's existing structure, not changing it.

The centrist, befitting their categorization here as conservative, not only accepts each and every one of these conservative tenets, but founds their thinking upon them. As one may expect, the conservative philosophical premises lead to conservatism in prescription, though as the treatment of "centrism" as a distinct category of conservative suggests centrism has its particular "prescription." The centrist specifically places a high stress on the maintenance of society-wide consensus behind existing social arrangements to prevent the division, radicalization, mass mobilization, upheaval, totalitarianism they fear most through the limitation of politics to a "pluralist," "pragmatic," and "civil" discourse. In practical terms this means the conduct of politics as a negotiation among society's various interests respectful of each other as all equally legitimate (pluralism) as those interests bargain for their ends with one another one separate issue at a time, without making any reference to "theories" regarding causes and connections, without thought for the structural and systemic (pragmatic), and equally without reference to what is true or false, right or wrong, fair and unfair, as with the inequities of power in these negotiations (civil).

In discussing this pluralist process the centrist stresses that this pluralism does not necessarily mean the public "getting what it wants"--indeed, may mean the public generally not getting what it wants. After all, it is not only the case that, as conservatives so readily hasten to point out when insisting on the need to limit democracy, a majority may tread on the rights of a minority; or that public foolishly demand the obviously impossible (such as, all other things being equal, more services and lower taxes at the same time). It is also the case that what the public wants is really often unclear, for even single-issue polls are imperfect, while translating broad preferences about a single issue into concrete policy is something else, and even a single voter is apt to have many different preferences that may conflict and require reconciliation, with the complexity of the problem all the greater at the level of a whole electorate. Moreover, pluralism entails its inevitable disappointments as the well-organized interest gets its unpopular way in the face of a contrary public opinion "fair and square" by the pluralist rules, and as the least-worst compromises leave many deeply dissatisfied. Centrists acknowledge that this makes for a frustrating situation for many, but holds that the discontented must simply bear the frustration as the alternative to the dangerous course of ideology, extremism, totalitarianism; to such a degree that the centrist regards any claim to rising above the frustrating "mess" of pluralism, like assertions about standing for "the will of the people," as inconsistent with and threatening to the system for which it stands, and indeed having a whiff of totalitarianism about them. Accordingly they are hostile to anything that would circumvent the pluralistic process (for instance, deeply distrusting the direct democracy of plebiscites), as they regard the public as obliged to settle not for participating in such decision-making, but simply for being represented in such decision-making (voting not on the laws, but on the choice of those who make them). Indeed, centrists hold those not abiding by these terms to be illegitimate, and marginalizing or even excluding them from the discourse a necessity for keeping the dialogue pluralistic, pragmatic, civil--"limiting democracy to preserve democracy."

As those appreciative of centrism's conservatism, and especially its anxiety to limit democracy, may guess, one can contrast the centrist stance with a very different, what one may refer to as small "d," democratic stance such as most intuitively associate with democracy. Taking seriously the principle of "government of the people, by the people, for the people" it is more favorable in its assessment of the broad public's intelligence and responsibility, more respectful of its right to participate in political life, and more supportive of the broadening and deepening of that participation. In practical terms this approach to political life entails the inclusion of a greater variety of viewpoints in the discourse, as the small "d" democrat takes a dim view of those who would accord themselves the authority to judge legitimacy and make exclusions on that basis. The democratic view also countenances public skepticism toward elites in line with the reality that they are neither infallible nor incorruptible, have often been wrong and corrupt in the past, and must accordingly not be above accountability to the public; while also regarding democratic government as obliging government policymaking to (significantly, generally, ultimately) respect public opinion, and a situation where the gap between policy and public preferences becomes great suspect as an oligarchy hiding behind the fig leaf of democratic procedure. Indeed, the supporter of democracy is prone to argue that while correctness is not a simple matter of majority opinion (publics not necessarily less fallible or corruptible than elites), on the whole wider participation is likely to lead to better decision-making than its limitation to an elite limited in size and perspective, especially provided that the public in question is properly engaged and well-enough informed to venture a meaningful opinion about the issues at hand--as indeed it can be, and as elites are obliged to help it to be, rather than cutting them out of the political process. The result is that in their view, in contrast with the conservative-centrist desire to limit democracy in the name of preserving it, more democratic government is apt to make for better government on the whole.

 Table 1: "Centrist" and "Democratic" Views of Democracy's Limits

Centrist View

Democratic View

Democracy must be limited if democracy is to be preserved because of the dangers of extremism and radicalization; and any frustration the public feels about those limitations borne as the sole alternative to worse (i.e. "totalitarianism").

Democracy can be understood as "government by the people, of the people, for the people" and a democratic society ought to work toward this ideal of public participation.

Many viewpoints are illegitimate because they are rooted in illegitimate ideas (i.e. "ideology") and conduce to division and radicalization threatening to society's structure and freedoms. Given that danger they should be excluded from the discourse for the sake of preserving pluralism, pragmatism, civility.

Within a democracy meriting the name every viewpoint should have its say in political discourse.

Many issues are insusceptible to the transparent presentation that would make them comprehensible to laypersons. One must therefore recognize the public as incompetent to judge of such matters, and its right to a say in public affairs accordingly qualified.

The public as a whole can understand the issues given the chance, and has a right to be informed about them so that it can have a say in them.

While public skepticism is perhaps inevitable the fact remains that the public's competence to judge such matters is limited, while their skepticism of elites' legitimate views, interests and power is illegitimate (often just so much "Know-Nothingism"), and undeserving of representation or address.

Public skepticism regarding elites' views, interests--and power--may be valid, and merits respectful attention.

Expectations of government deference to public opinion are simplistic and dangerous given that public opinion may be ambiguous; the public may not know best; and pluralism entails a complex play of interests over a complex constellation of issues; all as demands for knowledge of/deference to public preferences smacks of totalitarian talk of "the people's will." Accordingly it is the public which has to defer to judgments by subject area experts and political elites as the public settles for being represented in the political process, rather than participating in it.

Democracy requires that government generally defer to public opinion in the end, with this extending to concrete policy decisions. Those desirous of the public choosing a particular course are obliged to trust to the free flow of information, and their persuasiveness, in getting it to "choose correctly"--the more in as broader participation by the public will likely produce superior outcomes to decision-making by a limited and perhaps narrowly based group.

 All of the foregoing translates to each tendency's understanding of how the news media ought to function in modern society. In line with the centrist's reserve toward the public's participation in public affairs, not least because of its pessimism about its ability to understand those affairs; the centrist's anxiety about what might agitate the dangerous public, and their associated desire to limit the conversation to the range of views unthreatening to the existing social structure; their insistence upon public deference to authority, and what authority tells it; and one might add, their epistemological pessimism that has them suspicious of claims about "truth"; they support the media drawing a line between "objective," apparently "Just the facts" reporting and opinion in practice excluding "big picture"-comprehending analysis; shutting a great many views out of the dialogue altogether lest they "legitimize the illegitimate"; and treating Establishment positions with deference--the public less to make up its mind than to accept the leadership of those who "know better," as they uphold the consensus behind the existing order.

By contrast in line with the democratic view's championing the public's right to participate in policymaking, and claims for its ability to do so constructively, those of more democratic views stress the media's aiding the public in understanding the issues to enable that constructive participation, and to that end prioritizing the public's right to know the truth above all else. This entails, among much else, the view that the media should seek out that truth wherever it finds it (if necessary, going to sources unapproved by elites), accept responsibility for equipping the public to understand the issues through patient explication of the essentials for making sense of them (background, etc.), and provide the public an abundance and variety of careful analysis of those essentials affording it different ways of thinking about the matter, so that its members can make up their minds in an informed way--with the media challenging authority wherever it would obstruct this process, whether by deceiving the public, or in any way attacking press freedom.

Table 2: "Centrist" and "Democratic" Views of the Media's Function in a Liberal Democracy

Centrist View

Democratic View

The media cannot equip the public to understand the issues of the day in a deep manner--such a level of understanding beyond the capacity of the public, and also beyond the media's competence.

It is the media's obligation to equip the public to understand the issues of the day so that it can have meaningfully informed opinions about them.

 

 

The media should eschew the platforming of illegitimate views--and more broadly refrain from any action which may appear to "legitimize the illegitimate."

The media should broaden its platform to include the widest possible range of sources and views.

The media is obliged to defer to governmental and other authorities.

The media is obliged to treat all the information that it receives critically, including the information it receives from authoritative-seeming "Establishment" sources, and authority itself.

The media should tidily distinguish between the reporting of fact ("objectivity"), and the presentation of opinion, eschewing the analysis and interpretation of events as outside the proper, narrowly defined, bounds of reporting.

In aiding public comprehension the media has a duty to, in an open but thorough manner, analyze and interpret the news that it reports.

Even if one can ascertain "truth" (a highly questionable proposition) other concerns may come in ahead of it--such as the national interest as understood by the elites who know best, which extends to the necessity of preserving and sustaining consensus (and by the same token, avoiding divisions threatening to social stability).

The media's duty to the truth--and the public's right to know it--is paramount.

 

 

 

 Of course, there exists a long-accumulated body of scholarly analysis of the functioning of the news media--much of which reads the practice of mainstream news media (the major newspapers, television broadcasts, etc.) as aligned with the centrist model, as against the "democratic" model presented here. As the author previously outlined it this includes the media's tendency to present the news as a mass of disconnected "factoids" divorced from context, background or analysis, or alternatively, "opinion" clearly identified as such (most often, rather than helping the public to think about a matter through thorough reporting, background, analysis, telling the public what to think about it). It also inclines to a general deference to "Establishment" sources of information and comment, and exclusion of other sources of information and opinion from the discussion; propensity for "one sidesism" when covering the great majority of issues where elite consensus exists and response to elite disagreement with the "false balance" popularly known as "both sidesism" (again, limiting the discourse, respecting elites, and setting consensus above actual address of any issues); and a privileging of "politics" over "policy" as it covers the events of the day (attention to consensus formation and respect for elites triumphing again, the more in as in their conservatism they take a very limited view of the scope for plausible, acceptable change in policy).

 Table 3: Mainstream Media Practice and Centrist Principles

Media Practice

Centrist Principle

Presentation of "disconnected factoids" or opinion.

Epistemological pessimism, discomfort with complexity, aversion to "big picture" thinking.

Deference to "Establishment" information and views, exclusion of much of the possible or actual range of public opinion from the discourse.

Bounding of "legitimate discourse," regard for elites and their judgment, exclusion of "extremes" from the discourse.

One Sideism/Both Sidesism

Epistemological pessimism and concern for consensus sustenance in stress on search for reconciliation of conflicts over the truth; deference to elite concern.

Politics Over Policy.

Attentiveness to consensus formation, regard for elites and their activity, reflection of greater room for attention to "politics" due to their centrist (conservative) view of the proper limits of change to policy.

 Altogether these principles, and their implications for the media's conceptions of what actually constitutes a news story (as filtered by, among much else, the tilt to politics over policy), the suitable sources of information and acceptable range of opinion on those matters (the readiness to heed the statements of the corporate spokesperson as against those of the whistleblower), and the modes of their presentation to the public (disconnected factoids, opinion, and very little in between), rooted in basic centrist-conservative views, comprehensively determine the news media's content. In doing so they may be said to make the functioning of the mainstream news media structurally centrist, and thus structurally conservative, in a way that more superficial studies of the biases of the news media conventionally overlook--the more broadly informative side of the media captive to its biases in its self-assessment as in everything else it does.

In explaining that pattern's prevalence one may very reasonably, as so much media criticism does, look to the economic imperatives of a mainstream media which is indisputably and importantly a business, and the acculturation, training, working conditions and self-interest of the individuals who staff that business at its higher levels, as ultimately the determinant of journalism's intellectual framework. Analyses of the news media's content from this standpoint (its ownership by business, sourcing of information, fear of offending powerful parties, eagerness to appeal to an affluent consumer base, etc.) have the media's practical motives broadly aligning with the modus operandi described here, as well as the prejudices prevailing broadly in society and particularly the social strata that dominate the news media, especially at its higher levels, and the consumer base it desires most (centrism the conservatism of the college-educated professional). However, it is also the case that the centrist-conservative mode of operation this relevance--this "ideology" of the news business--not only reinforces the media's operatives in what business imperatives, career interests, or the conservative impulses of the relevant personnel encourage or compel, but helps organize, regularize and legitimize their conduct in line with all those factors. Thus the centrist thinking described here turns what would otherwise be a cynical cowering before ownership, profit and power into an apparently high-minded "professional practice" apparently remote from the crasser factors at work both in the minds of the media personnel, and a great many outside observers. In doing so it is also far from incidental that the understanding of how the news media should operate the author describes as centrist has made it difficult for many in and out of the field to see that anything may even be undesirable about it, let alone imagine that the news media could or should operate in any other fashion.

No comments:

Subscribe Now: Feed Icon